What to Do if a Team Member or Employee is Not Working Out

Sometimes, when working in a team or managing a group of employees, you might notice that someone is not doing their job well. This can be tough for everyone, including the person struggling. But it’s important to handle the situation carefully and fairly. If you’re a manager or a team leader, you can help the person improve or decide if they need to move on.

Here are some simple steps to follow if a team member or employee is not working out.

1. Talk to the Person Privately

The first thing you should do is talk to the team member privately. Everyone makes mistakes, and sometimes people don’t realize there’s a problem. When you speak with them, be kind but clear about what the issue is. Instead of blaming them, focus on the behavior or performance that needs to improve.

For example, instead of saying, “You’re always late,” you could say, “I’ve noticed you’ve been coming in late. Let’s figure out why this is happening and how we can fix it.” This way, the conversation stays positive and solution-focused.

2. Give Clear Feedback

It’s important to give feedback that is easy to understand. Let the person know what they are doing wrong, but also tell them what they are doing right. Positive feedback can encourage them to keep trying. Make sure your instructions are specific so they know exactly what they need to change.

For instance, if an employee is not meeting deadlines, explain how it affects the team and what they can do to improve. You could say, “When reports are late, it delays our entire project. Can we set up a schedule so we can meet deadlines together?”

3. Offer Help and Support

Sometimes, people struggle because they need more training or support. As a leader, it’s your job to offer resources that can help them succeed. Ask if there’s anything they need to do their job better. Maybe they need extra training, a mentor, or even just more time to learn their role.

You can also help by setting clear goals. Give them small, manageable tasks to work on so they can improve step by step. Checking in regularly to see how they’re doing can also make a big difference.

4. Set a Time for Improvement

Once you’ve had a conversation and offered help, it’s important to set a timeline for improvement. This lets the team members know that they need to take action, but it also gives them a fair chance to get better.

For example, you could say, “Let’s meet again in two weeks to see how things are going. By then, I hope to see improvements in your punctuality.” Having a clear timeline keeps everyone accountable and shows that you are serious about finding a solution.

5. Document the Process

It’s a good idea to keep records of your conversations and any steps you’ve taken to help the employee improve. This could include notes from your meetings, feedback you’ve given, or resources you’ve provided. Documentation is helpful if the problem continues, and you need to show that you’ve taken the right steps to support the person.

It also shows the team members that you’ve been fair and professional throughout the process.

6. Make a Decision

If the team member or employee still isn’t improving after you’ve given them feedback and support, you may have to make a tough decision. Sometimes, despite your best efforts, the person just isn’t the right fit for the team. This could be because they don’t have the necessary skills, or their behavior affects the team’s success.

If that’s the case, you may need to let them go. Before you do, make sure you’ve given them a fair chance to improve and followed any company policies about performance issues.

7. Be Compassionate

If you do have to let someone go, try to do it in a kind and respectful way. Losing a job is hard, and how you handle the situation can make a big difference in how the person feels afterward. Thank them for their efforts, and if possible, offer guidance or resources to help them in the future.

For example, you could say, “I appreciate the work you’ve put in, but it seems like this role isn’t the best fit. I’d be happy to provide a reference for jobs that match your strengths better.”

***

Dealing with a team member or employee who is not working out can be difficult, but by following these steps, you can handle the situation fairly and professionally. Remember to communicate clearly, offer support, and give the person a chance to improve. If things still don’t work out, it’s important to make a thoughtful decision that benefits both the team and the individual.